Composting Basics: 9 Items You Should Never Compost

Composting basics a blue shovel and kitchen food scraps.
My Garden Life
August 3, 2026
Table of Contents

Getting started with composting can be intimidating. However, in practice, composting basics are quite simple. You set up a heap or a bin, add a variety of plant-based scraps, and let the magic happen!

In this guide, we’re focusing on what materials not to add. These include items that break down too slowly, attract pests, or introduce contamination hazards. 

Choosing What to Compost

When you’re getting started with backyard composting, it’s best to stick with materials that break down rapidly with no complications. Your pile should contain a mix of nitrogen-rich greens (such as fruit and veggie scraps) and carbon-rich browns (such as dried leaves and cardboard).

Your compost pile shouldn’t contain manufactured products, harmful chemicals, or materials that don’t come from plants.

Some of the items listed below (such as cigarette butts) should never be composted. Others, such as avocado pits, are compostable—they just require a bit more effort or time.

If you’re new to composting, or if you prefer a no-hassle process, here are nine items you shouldn’t add to your compost heap.

1. Remove Produce Stickers Before Composting

The small stickers that come on grocery store produce are made from various non-biodegradable, non-recyclable materials. Compostable stickers exist, but they’re not common. Standard stickers don’t break down at all in the time it takes for other materials to form compost.

If you compost banana peels and other produce skins, form a habit of removing stickers before tossing the scraps. Otherwise, when it’s time to use your finished product, you’ll be stuck picking those grimy little stickers out of your soil.

Green apples at the market with bar code stickers attached.

2. Keep Meat, Bones, and Dairy Out of the Compost Pile

Most people who practice home composting choose to completely avoid all meat, bones, and dairy waste.

Complications with animal-based food scraps include:

  • Bones decompose very slowly.
  • Dairy fat can slow down the composting process.
  • Meat and dairy waste may attract animals like dogs, rats, coyotes, and bears.
  • Meat and dairy waste may spread diseases or parasites to wildlife.
Close up of plate of chicken bones.

If you’re ambitious about composting as much as possible, then there are strategies for incorporating these materials. For example, bokashi is a fermentation process that makes it easier to quickly compost a wider variety of scraps. However, if you want to keep things simple, completely avoid animal-based materials (with clean egg shells being the notable exception).

3. “Compostable” Plastic and Packaging

Commercial packaging and other products labeled “compostable” are usually not suitable for home composting systems. The “compostable” label is not highly regulated in most places. Thus, items with this label may break down very slowly or may require specific conditions for composting. Unless you can verify that a piece of compostable plastic or packaging will break down in your pile, don’t add it.

Plastic bags of vegetable scraps tossed on a compost pile.

4. Most Glossy Paper Does Not Compost Well

Paper is compostable. However, many paper products are coated in non-compostable coatings made from plastic or wax. This can include many types of gift wrap and printed gift bags.

Crumpled holiday gift wrap ready to be discarded.

Ideal paper products for composting include:

  • Corrugated cardboard
  • Cardboard toilet paper tubes and paper towel tubes
  • Cardboard egg cartons
  • Paper napkins or paper towels (as long as they aren’t contaminated by any non-compostable materials)

If your compost pile lacks brown materials, then these paper products are helpful carbon-rich ingredients to add. Other paper products should be avoided. If your pile already contains plenty of browns (such as dead leaves), then you might achieve the best environmental outcome by recycling all your paper waste.

Composting basics - shredded cardboard provides brown material in a compost bin.

5. It’s Best to Keep Pet Waste Out of the Compost Bin

Most commercial kitty litter is not compostable. Animal droppings are compostable, but they’re a health hazard if the compost they form ends up in your veggie garden.

Pet waste can also transfer medicines that can kill your compost pile’s worms. If you want to compost pet waste, do your research and choose a safe method. Otherwise, keep these materials out of your compost bin.  

A woman cleaning a litter box with a small cat nearby.

6. Cigarette Butts don’t Belong in Your Compost

Tobacco is a plant, so you may be tempted to toss cigarette butts into your compost pile. Unfortunately, cigarettes are loaded with toxic chemicals. Plus, cigarette filters contain plastic. Therefore, cigarettes shouldn’t be composted, with no exceptions.

A pile of cigarette butts tossed on a compost pile.

7. Invasive Weeds Can Cause Compost Problems Later

If you remove weeds that you don’t want spreading on your property or elsewhere, don’t compost them. This composting basics recommendation applies to any invasive weed, as well as toxic plants such as poison ivy. Weeds are resilient, and their seeds can spread during or after the composting process.

Secure methods for composting weeds involve high heat or preliminary steps to kill the seeds. For low-effort composters, it’s wiser to safely dispose of invasive weeds, rather than adding them to your bin.

A bucket of freshly pulled weeds sits on a brick garden path next to potted herbs and flowers.

8. Fire Ash is Best Discarded

Ashes from barbecues, firepits, or fireplaces may contain toxic chemicals. They can also spike a compost pile’s pH level, thus killing off helpful microbes.

In small quantities, ashes can be a helpful material to add to compost piles or garden beds.  However, it’s important to carefully follow guidelines for the type of ash you’re using. If you’d rather play it safe, simply dispose of ashes as a garbage product rather than adding them to your compost. Make sure ashes are completely cool before adding to your garbage to avoid fire hazards.

A man adding wood post chunks to a fire in a freestanding metal fire pit.

9. Composting Avocado Pits and Other Extremely Dense Plant Scraps

Certain plant-based scraps are so dense and fibrous that they break down very slowly. These include avocado pits, corn cobs, melon rinds, and nut shells. These items are okay if you don’t mind their slow pace, or if you break them apart to speed up decomposition. However, if you want to keep things simple, then avoid adding these dense scraps to your pile.

Old corn cobs decaying slowly in a compost pile.

More Ideas for Hassle-Free Composting Basics

Composting doesn’t have to be complicated. In fact, it can be as simple as burying food scraps in shallow holes and letting nature take over. Learn more about this easy, alternative way to reduce food waste and improve soil in our Guide to Direct Composting.

A man tossing a bowl of kitchen scraps into a hole for direct composting.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

The Garbage Garden: Vegetables you Can Regrow

The Garbage Garden: Vegetables you Can Regrow

Get more out of your vegetable purchases. You can create a garden from the vegetable scraps that might otherwise go in the compost pile or get tossed into the garbage.
How to Improve Soil Drainage

How to Improve Soil Drainage

Healthy soil drainage is essential for your plants to thrive. Learn how to make soil drain better with these tips.
Compost Tips for Beginners

Compost Tips for Beginners

Start composting with these tips and basic steps!
No results found.

Related Posts

How to Amend Clay Soil

How to Amend Clay Soil

How to Test Soil pH

How to Test Soil pH

How to Improve Sandy Soil to Grow Healthier Plants

How to Improve Sandy Soil to Grow Healthier Plants

No results found.
frost map with dates

Frost Map with Dates

USDA zone finder with zip code search and maps

USDA Zone Finder

plant library

Plant Library

Save plants to your personal library

Join My Garden Club to access more features

Already a member?
Log in now

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This

Share this post with your friends!